The Amazing Quran

By Gary Miller

Introduction

The Quran is the last revealed Word of God. It is a record of the exact words revealed by God to the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) through the Angel Gabriel. It was then dictated to his Companions who memorized it, and it was written down by scribes. The Quran is in every detail the unique and miraculous text which was revealed to Muhammad fourteen centuries ago. Not one word of its 114 chapters has been changed over the centuries.The Quran deals with all subjects which concern us as human beings: wisdom, doctrine, worship, and law, but its basic theme is the relationship between God and His creatures.

There are also many verses in the Quran concerned with natural phenomena that are astounding. It is impossible to explain their presence in humans terms, given the state of knowledge at the time the Quran was revealed.

In the West, such statements had never before formed the subject of a scientific communication until recent times. On 9th November 1976, an unusual lecture was given at the French Academy of Medicine. Its title was ‘Physiological and Embryological data in the Quran’ and was delivered by the famous French physician Dr. Maurice Bucaille. His reason for doing this was that “our knowledge of these disciplines is such, that it is impossible to explain how a text produced at the time of the Quran could have contained ideas that have only been discovered in modern times.The citations included in this pamphlet appeared in the Quran during the 7th century C.E.

The Prophet Muhammad was himself illiterate and was living among illiterate people. The Arabs at that time worshipped idols and believed in horoscope and magic and were superstitious. The Arabs very actively opposed the teachings advanced by the Prophet through his revelations.This short article is for you to read and to consider. Because the subject matter is so vast, we have space to mention only a few brief facts from the Amazing Qur’an.

The Creation of the Universe

“Do not the unbelievers see that the heavens and the earth were joined together, then We clove them asunder? And We made from water every living thing. Will they not then believe?”(21:30) This verse is specifically addressed to non-believers, and touches upon the creation of the universe and the origins of all life. The Quran mentions the existence of a gaseous mass (41:11) which is unique and whose elements, although at first fused together  subsequently became separated (fatq). The separation process resulted in the formation of multiple worlds, a notion which crops up dozens of times in the Quran (1:1): “Praise be to God, Lord of the Worlds.” [1,2]

The Origins of Life

“And We made from water every living thing.Will they not then believe?” (21:30)

The building blocks of all living things are called cells. They are the basic units of life.

Protoplasm (cytoplasm nucleus) is the substance of all living things. Cytoplasm is a jelly-like material consisting of water and dissolved substances. The constitution of protoplasm is about 80-85% water. Without water life is not possible. [2]

None of the myths on the origins of life that abounded at the time of the Quran are present in the text. Furthermore, the fact that all life originated from water would not have been a very easy thing to convince people of 1400 years ago, especially in the desert!

The Expansion of the Universe

The expansion of the universe is the most imposing discovery of modern science. Today it is a firmly established concept and the only debate centres around the way this is taking place.

“The heaven, We have built it with power. Verily, We are expanding it.” (51:47)‘We are expanding it’ is the translation of the plural present particle musi’una of the verb ausa’a meaning “to make wider, more spacious, to extend, to expand.” Some translators were unable to grasp the meaning and provided mistaken translations. Others sense the meaning, but were afraid to commit themselves eg. Hamidullah talks of the widening of the heavens and space, but he includes a question mark. Zidan & Zidan, and The Supreme Council for Islamic Affairs refer to the expansion of the universe in totally unambiguous terms. [1,2]

The Mountains

Mountains have always been looked upon as conspicuous landforms, characterized by lofty protrusions above their surroundings, high peaks and steep sides. However, the Quran accurately describes mountains as stabilizers for the Earth that hold its outer surface firmly, lest it should shake with us, and as pickets (or pegs) which hold that surface downwardly as a means of fixation.”Have we not made the earth an expanse, and the mountains stakes (awtad)?” (78:6-7) and “And God cast into the ground mountains standing so that it does not shake with you.” (31:10). [1,3]

The Developing Human Embryo

Statements referring to human reproduction and development are scattered throughout the Quran. It is only recently that the scientific meaning of some of these verses has been fully appreciated. The Quran determines that human development passes through stages (39:6). The realization that the human embryo develops in stages was not discussed and illustrated until the 15th century.

The staging of human embryos was not described until the 20th century. Streeter (1941) developed the first system of staging which has now been replaced by a more accurate system proposed by O’Rahilly (1972). However, the Quran was the first source to mention this (23:12-16).

The Quran and Hadith also state that both parents share in the origins of the offspring: “O mankind! We created you from male and female.” (49:13) and “We created mankind from a mixed drop (nutfah-amshaj).” (76:2) The mixed drop refers to the mixture and convergence of a small quantity of sperms with the ovum (and its associated follicular fluid) to form the zygote. It has the form of a drop and consists of a mixture of male and female secretions.”Then we made the drop into a leech-like structure (‘alaqah).” (23:14) ‘alaqah in Arabic means (i) to cling and stick to a thing; (ii) a leech or bloodsucker; (iii) a suspended thing; and (iv) a blood clot.

Amazingly, each of the meanings for ‘alaqah can be applied to human prenatal development.For example, taking ‘alaqah to mean a leech we find that the embryo is surrounded by amniotic fluid just as a leech is surrounded by water. The human embryo clings to the mothers womb, in the same way that a leech clings to the skin. A leech is a pear shaped organism and thrives on bloodsucking. The diagram above clearly indicates that the shape of the embryo does in fact resemble a leech! At this stage the cardiovascular system has started appearing and the embryo is now dependant on the maternal blood for its nutrition like a leech! As there were no microscopes or lenses available in the 7th century, people could not have known that the embryo has this leech-like appearance.”Then out of that leech-like structure We made a chewed lump (mudghah).” This statement is from Surah 23:14. The Arabic word mudghah means “chewed substance or chewed lump.” Towards the end of the 4th week, the human embryo looks somewhat like a chewed lump of flesh. The chewed appearance results from the somites which resemble teeth marks. The somites represent the beginnings of the vertebrae (backbone). (For a detailed discussion concerning the Quran and modern embryology see 1,2,4,5,6).

Lost Civilizations

In the 89th chapter of the Quran, the city of “Iram” is mentioned: “Have you not seen how your Lord dealt with Aad, of the city of Iram, with lofty pillars the like of which was never created in any land?” Iram has been unknown to history, so much so that it apparently became an embarrassment to some Muslim commentators of the Holy Quran. In 1975, in North-Western Syria the ancient city of Ebla was excavated. Ebla is over 4500 years old. In the ruins of the Palace Library they found the largest collection of cuneiform clay tablets ever discovered – around 15,000. Written in the oldest Semitic language yet identified, the tablets reveal that Ebla rivalled Egypt and Mesopotamia as a major power of the ancient world. They found in there a record of all the cities that Ebla used to do business with including one IRAM! [7,8,9]

What happened to the body of Pharaoh of the Exodus?

The Biblical version of Pharaoh’s story states that he was drowned in the pursuit of Prophet Moses (Exodus 14:28-29). Unknown to the world till only of late, the Holy Quran made a definite prediction about the preservation of the body of that same Pharaoh of Moses’ time 10:90-92: “This day We shall save you in your body so that you may be a sign for those that come after you”. The body was discovered in the tomb of Amenhotep II in 1898. [2,12]

The resting place of Noah’s Ark

The Bible states that “And the Ark rested… upon the mountains of Ararat.” Genesis 8:4. According to the Holy Quran (11:44): “The Ark came to rest upon Al-Judi.” According to recent evidence from an archaeological find in Eastern Turkey, experts believe they may have discovered the remains of an ancient vessel whose dimensions mirror those of Noah’s Ark as told in the Bible. However, the discovery was made on Al-Judi! [10,11]

The Holy Quran:- God’s final Guidance to Mankind

“How could a man, from being illiterate, become the most important author in terms of literary merits in the whole of Arabic literature? How could he the pronounce facts of a scientific nature that no other human being could have possibly known at that time, and all this, without once making the slightest error in his pronouncement on the subject?” (Dr. Maurice Bucaille).

You owe it to yourself to find out the TRUTH about : ISLAM, the Holy Quran and the Life and teachings of God’s final Messenger, Muhammad.

The message of ISLAM is simple:

There is nothing worthy of worship except GOD alone, and Muhammad is his messenger and servant. There are today, over one-thousand million followers of ISLAM. Find out the truth!

NOTES:

[1] VIDEO TAPE: This is the TRUTH

[2] The Bible, the Qur’an & Science, by Dr. Maurice Bucaille, American Trust Publications.

[3] The Geological concept of Mountains in the Qur’an, by Prof. Z. R. El-Nagger, IIIE, USA.

[4] “A scientist’s interpretation of references to embryology in the Qur’an.”, Keith L. Moore, Journal of the Islamic Medical Association of North America (18:15) 1986.

[5] The Developing Human: Clinically oriented embryology with ISLAMIC ADDITIONS, Keith L. Moore and A. A. Azzindani, 3rd Ed., Dar Al-Qiblah and WB Saunders, 1983.

[6] Human Development as Described in the Qur’an and Sunnah, Various contributors, Islamic Academy for Scientific Research, ISBN 0-9627234-1-4, 1992.

[7] The Amazing Qur’an, Gary Miller.

[8] National Geographic, December, 1978.

[9] Ebla – A revelation in archaeology, Chaim Bermant and Michael Weitzman, Time Books, 1979.

[10] VIDEO TAPE: Quest for the Ark, Channel 4 documentary.

[11] The Discovery of Noah’s Ark, D. Fasold, Wynwood Press, 1988.

[12] Moses and Pharaoh: The Hebrews in Egypt, Dr. Maurice Bucaille, NTT Mediascope Inc., Japan, 1994

33 Comments

  1. Masha Allah, very good article, deserves to be read by every human being, Thank you Iqbal Bhai.

  2. John Leonard says:

    I cannot see any evidence in the facts, just because we cannot prove who wrote the Quran doesn't mean that God did it.

  3. Anonymous says:

    Dear John, If you have any other explanation I am more than willing to listen to it…

  4. Anonymous says:

    The oldest copy of the Quran can be found in Turkey. It is from the 7th century. This book contains facts that were discovered very recently by the modern science…So if one doubts about the age of the Quran it is easy to radiocarbon date it. If one doubts about some interpretations, there are verses where there is none like the one about water and life. If one has other reasons to persist rejecting objective facts, He or She is being dishonest…

  5. Asjid Ali says:

    are you mad? it's written by GOD .can you give me evidence tha bible written by GOD?dont say anything without knowledge.ok??

  6. Asif Sadiq says:

    peace be up on u all…
    dear john leonard, u are doubtfull with the author of quran…. sure take ur own time and do study.. … no other best explanation….
    and if u wish to find one of the best debates which can give rational arguements.. u can search for "the big debates" and there are number of debates with famous athiest like lawrence krauss…
    may almight guide u to the right path….

  7. @John. don't diss the book, mate. I'm Catholic from the Philippines and know of how Holy the Quran is for true believers of Islam. And as Catholics are taught [by Jesus through the bible and the magisterium and the holy Spirit], read in Spirit and in truth. The spirit of the Quran is a bit literally and not yet spiritually interpreted at times, kinda Pharisaic folks, really, and the level of prayer is a bit servile and not yet as "friends who know what their master is about" level but baby steps. Jesus predicts one day people will worship God in spirit and in truth, and beyond just following their religions. Which means imbued with the holy Spirit of God (and Jesus, who Catholics believe is God made man, not man made God, ok, and whom Muslims believe, was given permission by God to have some divine qualities. Well, who knows… even Jesus says you can disbelieve in him and that's forgivable, but just think and feel the Spirit for yourself, then you will really know.). Hehe, hope I don't sound like one from the frying pan of Muslms to the fires of Christianity, haha. Masha Allah and bring us all to unity in Spirit and in Truth.

  8. HOW DO YOU EXPLAIN THE AYAT WHERE IT SAYS ALLAH FIRST CREATE THE BONES , THEN FLESH AND THEN DECIDE IF IT WILL BE BOY OR GIRL? ACCORDING TO MODERN SCIENCE ITS COMPLETELY WRONG BECAUSE THE FIRST GENES DECIDE THE SEX, THEN FLESH IS CREATED AND THEN BONES. THESE AYATS COMPLETELY WRONG ACCORDING TO SCIENCE.

  9. Kardo Muhammed Salh says:

    during the seventh week the skeleten begin to spread throught the body (sclerotome) , and the bones take familiar shapes at the end of the week and during the eighth week the muscles(myotome) take their positions around the bone forms, later on take the human being shape…. too many articles on that , you can search too many images for sclerotome and myotome formation which you can see that the myotomes form around the sclerotome in steps…

  10. Kardo Muhammed Salh says:

    look at this webpage:
    https://www.inkling.com/read/larsens-human-embryology-schoenwolf-bleyl-brauer-francis-west-4th/chapter-4/somite-differentiation-forming

    the sclerotome develops then dermatomyotomes will be divided in to dermatome and myotome, this is a miracle in quran.

  11. Kardo Muhammed Salh says:

    for what you said about girl or boy, i think you hit nothing , there is nothing to correct to you, revise the hadiths and ayat in quran about male or female gender

  12. I HAVE READ OTHER ARTICLES REGARDING WHAT COMES FIRST (BONES OR FLESH) WHICH SAYS DIFFERENTLY. LETS SAY ITS TRUE BONES COMES FIRST. DOES THAT MAKE QURAN MIRACULOUS ? THAT MEANS YOU DIDNT READ MUCH OLDER BOOKS WHICH TALK ABOUT MANY SCIENTIFIC FACTS WHICH WAS IMPOSSIBLE TO KNOW AT THAT TIME. IN HINDU "VAGABAT GITA" IT EXPLAINED ABOUT GALAXIES (!) AND SAID THE DISTANCE BETWEEN TWO GALAXIES CAN BE THOUSAND LIGHT YEARS. THATS JUST ONE EXAMPLE OF MANY. HOW COME BEFORE 5000 YEARS PEOPLE KNEW ABOUT GALAXY WITHOUT TELESCOPE. SO THIS BOOK MUST BE MIRACULOUS TOO
    . RIGHT?

  13. Kardo Muhammed Salh says:

    allah sent more than 124000 prophets through out all decades, and what you replied may be one of them, many similiar sciences could be discovered because allah didnt sent only one prophet muhammad (PBUM) , and that aya is related to early pregnancy alllah says later on when both the bones and fleshes formed we will give it the shape of human being .

  14. ACCORDING TO QURAN AND HADITH ( I CAN QUOTE IF YOU WANT), AT THE FINAL STAGE THE ANGELS ASK ALLAH WHETHER IT WILL BE BOY OR GIRL. THEN ALLAH DECIDES. THE SEX OF BABY IS DECIDER ON THE VERY MOMENT OF CREATING THE FIRST HUMAN CELL. SO ITS OBVIOUS QURAN GOT IT WRONG. I HOPE YOU WILL NOT FIND ANY OTHER EXPLANATION BY CHANGING THE MEANING OF ARABIC WORDS BY SUITING YOUR NEEDS.

  15. Kardo Muhammed Salh says:

    and there is no artcile suggent that fleshes (myotomes) will be formed earlier, if it is present let me know

  16. Kardo Muhammed Salh says:

    i think you got it in a wrong way
    firs i have no needs proving the truth
    second what is (FINAL STAGE) ???? there is no such a word in any hadith or aya
    third here is all hadiths and aya :
    1- Females have XX chromosomes, that is, they can only give one X chromosome. But since males have XY chromosomes then men can either give the X or the Y chromosome. This means that it is actually the males who determine the sex of the baby (by giving either the X or the Y chromosome).

    [Quran 53:45-46] And He (Allah) creates pairs, male and female, from semen emitted.

    2- iam as a doctor as i know It is an established fact that the sex of an embryo is determined to be created in the second half of the sixth week!

    In a hadith of our beloved prophet Muhammad (pbuh), it is stated that Allah (The All Mighty) determines to create the sex after 40 (Or 45) nights: did you mean by the FINAL STAGE this ?????

    From Hudhayfa in al-Bukhari and Muslim states:
    "The angel is sent to the (sperm-and-ovum drop) after it has settled in the uterus for FORTY OR FORTY-FIVE NIGHTS and says, "Lord! Is it to be wretched or happy?" Then this is inscribed. Then he says, "Lord! Is it to be male or female?" Then this is inscribed…"
    (Muslim: Book 33: Hadith 6392)
    As you see, scientists state that the determination of whether the baby will be a daughter or son occur in the second half of WEEK SIX. (“..occurs in the second half of week six…”)

    6 WEEKS= 40 NIGHTS (as the hadith stated, from 40 to 45 nights)

    It is quite amazing that this is said at a time when nobody in Arabia knew a jack about science, and it would be ridiculous to say that Muhammed (pbuh) maybe had a microscope in one of his tents.

    you should know that tha angels ask allah if boy or girl, allah decided during fertilizatin that it will be male or female, but gross appearance will be at 40-45 nights.

  17. MAY BE?? ASSUMPTION OR WILD GUESS ? ARE YOU ASSUMING "VEDAS , PURANA, UPANISHAD WAS SENT BY ALLAH AND THESE PEOPLE ONEDAY SUDDENLY WOKE UP HINDUS?? THATS A LOT OF IMAGINATION ! DO WE GET SCIENCE FROM PROPHETS ? SINCE WHEN THATS A FACT? ARE THESE PROPHETS SPREADING SCIENCE OR RELIGION? WHICH PROPHET SCIENTIFICALLY ENLIGHTENED WHICH AREA SPCEFICALLY ? ANY IDEA? I KNOW SOME …. 1. ARCHIMEDES 2. UCLEDES 3. ARZOVOTTO(INDIA) 4. GALILEO 5. PTOLEMY ….. CAN YOU GIVE ME ONE PROPHETS NAME LIKE THESE PROPHETS OF SCIENCE?

  18. Kardo Muhammed Salh : THERE IS NO WORD FINAL STAGE. I MEANT AFTER THE FORMATION OF THE BABY THE ANGEL ASKS IF IT WIL BE BOY OR GIRL. THEN ALLAH DECALRES IT. I WILL QUOTE THE HADITH LATER.

  19. Kardo Muhammed Salh says:

    Anisur Rahman allah sent his messengers as prophets not as scientists, each prophet with a message from allah, for each level of education must have messages, islamic message (quran) must contain scientific messages to proove its truth for some people who represent themselves to beleive in nothing but sciences , all we have in quran are 25 prophets named , we have no evidance for the reminder , it is guess i dont know, all that i know apart from scientific miracles in quran the greatest miracle of quran is that it is been kept by allah since 1400 years, this not the case for bible.

  20. Kardo Muhammed Salh says:

    ok bring the hadith.

  21. Kardo Muhammed Salh 1. I DONT KNOW WHY YOU EXPLAINED THE CHOROMOSOME THEORY. ITS LIKE YOU TAKE ONE LINE FROM QURAN AND BORROW 10 LIINES OF TOUGH RESEARCHED SCIENTIFIC FACTS TO PROVE THAT VERY SUPERFICIAL ( RIGHT OR WRONG) OR INCOMPLETE DETAILS AYATS.
    2. SURA 53 – HALF OF THE WORLD, THOUSANDS OF YEARS BEFORE THE QURAN KNEW SEMEN CAUSES PREGANCY.. DO YOU WANT ME TO QUOTE HINDU RELIGIOUS SCRIPTURE TO PROVE THAT?

    3. AS A DOCTOR YOU KNOW WHEN THE SEX IS DETERMINED. WHY DONT YOU SHOW ME THAT FROM QURAN? THAT QURAN ALSO SAYS WHEN SEX IS DETERMINED ON FIRST MOMENT? ACCORDING TO QURAN OR HADITHS WHEN AT WHAT STAGE OF EMBRYO THE SEX IS DETERMINED ? CAN YOU ANSWER THAT?

    4. YES ACCORDING TO HADITH ALL DETERMINES SEX AFTER THE EMBRYO IS CREATED AND GOING THROUGH LATER STAGE OF FORMATION.

    5. MAN , ACCORDING TO SCIENCE SEX OF BABY IS DETERMINED DURING FORMATION OF FIRST CELL. NOT AFTER 40 NIGHTS..!!!

    6. NOBODY IN GREECE BEFORE 4000 YEARS HAD MICROSCOPE TOO. BUT THEY KNEW A LOT OF PRIMITIVE SCIENCE , LOT MORE THAN ARABS AT THAT PERIOD. YOU DIDNT READ THE GREEK SCHOLARS BOOK ON CREATION OF EMBRYO. WHICH WASNT PERFECT SCIENCE THOUGH. BUT ALSO VERY AMAZING …. DOES THAT MAKE THEM PROPHETS??

    7. WHERE DID YOU FIND ALLAH DETERMNES THE SEX DURING FERTILIZATION ? PLEASE QUOTE AND DONT ADD UP YOUR IMAGINATION. ANYTHING YOU SAY MUST BE IN QURAN OR HADITH. WHERE DID YOU FIND THE WORD "GROSS APPEARANCE" IN THAT HADITH ? IT WAS TALKING ABOUT ANGEL ASKING WHETHER IT WILL BE BOY OR GIRL. BEFORE 50 YEARS NOBODY EXPLAINED THIS HADITH THE WAY YOU ARE EXPLAINING NOW. SURELY EVERBODY TOOK THE MEANING SEX IS DETERMINED LATER. YOU ARE SUITING YOUR EXPLANATION TO MODERN SCIENCE.

  22. Kardo Muhammed Salh 1. IF ALLAH DIDNT SEND THEM AS SCIENTIST WHY ARE YOU PRETENDING THEM TO BE A MAN OF SCIENCE. BEFORE 100 YEARS DID ANYBODY LIKE YOU TRIED TO PROVE QURAN IS FULL OF SCIENCE? SURELY NO.

    2. WHAT LEVEL OF EDUCATION DID THE PROPHETS HAVE ?

    3. HAVE YOU READ THE BOOK "INFERNO" BY DANTE ? THERE ARE LOT OF SCIENTIFIC MIRACLES IN THAT BOOK. I WILL QUOTE THAT HOPEFULLY ANOTHER DAY.

    4. REGARDING LETTER CHANGE OF RELIGIOUS BOOKS – CHRISTIANS DONT REALLY CLAIM BIBLE AS A MIRACLE THE WAY YOU CLAIM. THEY NEVER SAY WHAT EXACTLY GOD SAID IS WRITTEN THERE WORD BY WORD , LETTER BY LETTER. THEY SAID BIBLE IS WRITTEN BY MEN WHO ARE INSPIRED BY GOD. WHATS THE POINT OF PROVING THAT WORDS OF BIBLE HAS CHANGED WHEN NOBODY CLAIMS IT AS A BOOK OF MIRACLE ?

    5. IF A BOOK DOESNT CHANGE IN THOUSAND YEARS DOES IT MAKE IT MIRACULOUS ? LET ME GIVE YOU A LIST OF BOOKS WHICH DIDNT CHANGE A LETTER ;

    A. ARISTOTLE'S 400 BOOKS WRITTEN BEFORE 3000 YEARS
    B. AT LEAST 20 RELIGIOUS BOOKS OF HINDUS LIKE VEDAS, PURAN MONUSHONGHITA, RAMAYANA, MAHAVARATA, WRITTEN BEFORE 5000 YEAR ( APPROXIMATELY)
    C. PLATO'S THE REPUBLICE
    D. SOPHOCLEUS BOOK ON PHILOSOPHY
    E. LOTS OF GREEK DRAMMAS
    F. HOMERS' ILIAD AND ODESSI AND LOTS MORE BOOK WHICH WERE WRITTEN BEFORE THOUSANDS OF YEARS

  23. Kardo Muhammed Salh says:

    Anisur Rahman 1- it is very obvious why i explained chromosomal theory , i mentioned that because quran says semen is the cause of male and female, not the pregnancy as u replied semen causes pregnancy, i said semen determines the gender in quran. this is never mentioned before .

    2- what incomplete aya i borowed ?

    3- in hadith sex will be determined grossly at 40-45 days after fertilization, when the angel asks allah after that peried, in quran sex will be determined during fertilization : surah al-najm aya 45-47 (????????? ?????? ????????????? ????????? ??????????? ( 45 ) ???? ???????? ????? ??????? ( 46 ) ??????? ???????? ??????????? ????????? ( 47 ) allah says he created male and female when fertilization occurs (?? ???? ??? ????) .(46
    4- the hadith talks about gross appearance when the baby's sex is formed the angel says allah it is male or female , the angel want to know so as to write .. it is determined previosly and well known by allah , this is for the angel, it is quite true by science that sex will be developed at the exact time of the hadith , but it is genetically defined during fertilization as mentioned in quran.
    5- you should know that the prophet muhammad PBUH was illeterate and if he is not a prophet how he knew these kinds of information. second he is a prophet not a scientist his duty is to deliver the message not to do scientific evidances , he is too much difference from greek.

  24. Kardo Muhammed Salh says:

    Anisur Rahman then regarding the letter change, quran is the book that has too much enemies inside and outside , they are trying to do any single change if they could do. they succeed in changing bible and tawrah and many others but not quran … this is not the plato's the republice book and all others. quran has international enemies.

    second thing is that what makes quran miraculous the prophet PBUH was unable even to write his name , how could bring such a book that changed the every aspect of life , the prophet muhammad by himself was miracle , a little part of quran is scientific miracle , people lived hundreds of years ago beleived in islam by this small video http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qVDRsM90QYI just watch it and you know why quran is miracle.

  25. Kardo Muhammed Salh 1. that ayat didnt say semen deternines gender. you are working hard to make that meaning to suite your need.. the ayat says allah creates male or female from semen. it doesnt say semen determines gender. you are twisting the meaning. if semen determines gender then why angel asks whether it will be boy or girl ?

    2. you are totally misinterpreting the meaning of that hadith. the angel asks in a way to make an inquiry if the baby will be boy or girl ( like we do when we dont know what baby will be), not that to finalize gross appearance (!!) , and give sexual organ. i think you are guessing sexual organ make a baby male or female. even before forming sexual organ a baby is already boy or girl. please dont invent a new meaning like zakir nayek. this is not the way this hadith was explained last 50 years. i am hearing a newfound meaning from you.

    3. the ayats is not clear at all that male or female determined by semen rather it means whether its male or female thats made from semen. you are making up new theories. i am not surprised though.

    4. i ddnt say it will arise 40-45 days

    5. where in the hadith talk about gross appearance ? are you inventing new meaning of arabic word like zakir nayek ?

    6. where in quran it says sex is genetically determined during fertilization ?? science says so nowadays. nobody in history in islam one maulana said that before 50 years. this is new theory coming out to make it suitablle with modern embryology.

    7. its a question mark whether prophet was illiterate or not and what is meant by literacy. Most probably prophet knew how to read and write only. but didnt go to school. but thats not certain. some seals were found with his signature on it. even someone is illiterate doesnt mean he cant have few basic knowledge. infact in previous civilizations lot of common people lot more science than the prophet. 5000 year old indian civilization had lot more knowledge regarding universe, stars , sun-moon rotation, mathematics….. does mean they had many prophets from where they got this science.

    8. yes you are right , his job is not to spread science. so dont try to prove him a scientist. and religion has no job about science. so dont try to prove quran is full of science. because purpose of religion is wellbeing of people and their lifestyle not building rockets.

  26. Kardo Muhammed Salh 1. YOU ARE NOT LEFT ALONE IN FEELING YOUR HOLY BOOK IS UNDER ATTACK. ZAKIR NAYEK IS ATTACKING HINDU AND CHRISTIAN SCRIPTURE EVERY DAY TO PROVE THESE FALSE. SEEMS OTHER RELIGIONS ARE UNDER ATTACK BY MUSLIMS TOO. IF NOBODY CAN SHOW A SINGLE QURAN WHICH HAS DIFFERENT SPELLING , DIFFRENT LETTER HOW CAN THEY PROVE QURAN CHANGED ITS LETTERS. SO THE QUESTION IS THERE DIFFERENT QURAN ?

    2. THE QUESTION IS CAN A ILLITERATE MAN WRITE AN EPIC BOOK. YOU DIDNT READ THE GREATEST POEMS IN ILIAD AND ODESSI WRITTEN BY HOMER. LET ALONE BEING EDUCATED IN HARVARD , HOMER WAS BLIND !! HOW COULD HE WRITE SUCH AN EPIC BOOK WITH THOUSANDS OF VERSE.

    3. DO YOU KNOW "MAHAVARAT" WAS WRITTEN BY INDIANS BEFORE 5 THOUSAND YEARS AND UNTIL NOW IT HAS HIGHEST NUMBER OF VERSE EVER . THESE VERSES ARE SO POETIC, WHO WROTE IT? DID HE STUDY IN OXFORD? DO WE NEED TO BE SO MUCH LITERATE TO WRITE A GREAT BOOK? THE WORLD HAD MANY GREAT LITERARY WORK BEFORE QURAN WRITTEN BY SEMI LITERATE-ILLITERATE MAN.

    4. IF QURAN IS MIRACLE , THERE ARE LOT OF OTHER GREAT BOOKS WHICH ARE MIRACLE TOO. HOW COME THEY ALSO KNEW SO MUCH SCIENCE THAT TIME?? ISNT THAT MIRACLE TOO?

  27. Kardo Muhammed Salh says:

    Anisur Rahman vey nice argument , let me explain
    leave my comments, let's say iam suiting it to my need, let's say no one explained like me, here is the explanation of our religious scientists regarding these ayah and hadiths who lived hundreds of years before, when there was not any scientific researches in these subjects,
    before qouting their thought let me tell you the terms they used : (mani , nutfa)

    (mani) means semen white ejaculation of men as well as women ejaculation.

    (nutfa) means a single unit of a semen , our old scientist think like that because allah says we created him from a nutfa of semen (???? ?? ???) … IAM NOT GOING TO SAY IT IS SPERM SO AS NOT ALLOW YOU SAY YOU ARE SUITING IT TO MODERN SCIENCE.

    allah says in quran surah insan aya 2 ( ??? ????? ??????? ?? ???? ????? ?????? ??????? ????? ?????) means we created human being by mixing (- amshaj ?????) a (single nutfa) (?? ????) of men and women so we made him listen and see. so the aya says every human being is created from a single nutfa of both father and mother.(DONT SAY YOU WORK HARD TO SUITE IT WITH MODERN SCIENCE).
    below is the thought of our old scientists

    (al-tabari) 1100 years ago: (?????) (nutfa amshaj) means mixture , a mixture of men and women nutfa.

    (al-hasan albasri) 1300 years ago: allah created human being from men and women both of them after their relationships mix their things if allah give them baby it is from both of them .

    ibn kathir 750 years ago: (amshaj) means mixture of things (nutfa amshaj) mixture of nutfa that is in men and women ,

    ibn hajar al asqalani 600 years ago: those scientists who claim that the sons has no relation to father is refused because all hadiths says the opposite of this. the father is the cause of sons. ( if iam suiting to modern science , at that time the science was against hadith and our religous scientists refused modern science of their age)

    ibn qaim al jawzi 680 years ago :daughters are from fathers and mothers, sons are from fathers ,although father's nutfa if not mixed with that of women will not create sons. (HOW YOU EXPLAIN THESE SENTENCES IN A TIME THAT THERE WERE NO SCIENCE AND IF SCIENCE WAS PRESENT WAS AGAINST THE HADITHS, AND WHY DO YOU EXPLAIN THAT THE HADITHS AND AYA DO NOT MEAN THAT SONS ARE FROM FATHERS

    HADITH MUSNAD IMAM AHMAD : a jew came to the prophet PBUH and asked him a question, he said i ask you a question from which human being is created , the prophet muhammad PBUH said from nutfa of man and nutfa of women, the jew said all previous prophets knew that.

    REGARDING the hadith of male and female when the angel asks allah it is male or female after 40 -45 days, please explain to me if modern science says the sex of the baby will be apparant by using ultrasound device at 40-45 days , how you correlate between science and this hadtih? why you insist that the hadith is wrong?? if our old scientists said boys are created by (father nutfa) when mixed to mother nutfa and by the hadith will be apparant at 40-45 days , dont you think mixing means fertilization and that of 40-45 days means gross appearance ??? islam is religion not science so you should know the scientific miracles will be discribes in normal language not scientific terms. despite the fact that what i replied to you was powered by our religous man thoughts who correctly understood the meaning of quran and all muslims now a day are on their roads. we can not say things that they didnot say it . we are not inventing in our religion.

    the prophet muhammad PBUM lived 40 yrs did nothing , after that certain age started to deliver the message, because he became a prophet at age of 40 yrs, he was accused of many things, almost all the days he was tortured as well as his freinds because of iman, he was hungry as well as his Friends for 3 yrs some of them died because of hunger and torture, he was illiterate and can not write , with in these facts and with in these miserable situations that all of them was in misery , from where he quoted these scientific facts if it is not from allah so it is from where? quran is for all humanity so it must contain enough evidence for all people till the day of judgement, quran is so much different from those mentioned books by you.. you know imagine you are washing your car and you are completely busy with that and listening to song during washing can you imagine you can discover how airports fly during car washing ?? or can you invent something new? of coarse not.. because it needs time and need to read data and read particularly about that subject.. but if happens with you, who will believe you ? no one will believe you unless you bring your discovery to them. of coarse you will not be able to do it. so what if that was the case of prophet muhammad PBUH, man was illiterate and never read any book and never did any scientific research add for that he was tortured all the time and was busy with deliverng the message of allah , if he stated about sciences what will be the explanation? the only explanation is true beleive that he is a messenger of allah, so Islam has enough arguments to make people beleive and folllow quran and hadith. the aim of these scientific quotes to make certain people know their creator, the aim is not delivering science…. because islam is a program not a science.

    regarding previous old stories you posted . actually it is very nice and i like it . they MAY have had prophets .. or they may have had scientists .. i can not say anything you are more near to them and you should proove it if their were prophets or not or they were actualy scientists , the difference is that scientists take effort to discover but prophets do nothing apart from delivering allah's message and what they say about science is from allah not by devoting time and doing alot of experimets to discover something new. because their aim is not science but defining allah as a creator.

  28. Kardo Muhammed Salh 1. SURA INSAN AYAT 2 :
    Sahih International
    Indeed, We created man from a sperm-drop mixture that We may try him; and We made him hearing and seeing.
    ** IN MY LANGUAGE AND ALL OTHER ENGLISH TRANSLATION OR ANY OTHER LANGUAGE I FOUND AND I CAN FIND THAT MEANING OF NUFTA ISNOT A "SINGLE UNIT SEMEN" RATHER IT IS "DROP OF SEMEN" . ARE YOU WORKING HARD TO CHANGE THE MEANING OF THE WORD TO MAKE IT LIKE SINGLE CELL OF SEMEN. SO THAT YOU CAN BE MORE CLOSER TO SCIENCE? HOWEVER ITS A COMMON MUSLIM DEFENSE MECHANISM TO CHANGE MEANING OF WORD. ( I WILL GIVE YOU LATER A LIST OF COMMON MUSLIM DEFENSE MECHANISM ).
    2. THE PRIMITIVE SCIENTIFIC FACT THAT MIXTURE OF SEMEN FROM MEN AND WOMEN CREATES EMBRYO IS SO COMMON BEFORE THOUSANDS OF YEARS, I AM AMAZED THAT YOU USE IT TO MAKE QURAN MIRACULOUS. SHALL I QUOTE ANCIENT GREEK THEORIES REGARDING THIS MATTER TO PROVE THAT THEY ALSO KNEW MORE THAN JUST FEW LINES IN QURAN. ?
    3. AL TABARI, IBN KATHIR KNEW ABOUT IT? SO DID HUNDRED OF ANCIENT GREEK, INDIAN SCHOLARS THOUSAND YEARS BEFORE THEY WERE BORN. IF I HAVE TIME I WILL QUOTE ANCIENT KNOWLEDGE FROM OTHER CIVILIZATION. WHAT MAKES YOUR THEORY INVALID IS THAT NOT ONLY QURAN BUT OTHER OLDER BOOKS AND PEOPLE WELL AWARE OF THAT INFACT MUCH MORE IN DETAILS
    4. AL QAIM : "DAUGHTERS ARE FROM FATHER AND MOTHER, SONS ARE FROM FATHER" WHAT AN ABSOLUTELY WRONG THEORY. YOU MISSED THE OTHER PART OF CHROMOSOME THEORY WHICH SAYS FATHERS CHROMOSOME (XY) AND MOTHERS CHROMOSOME (YY) CREATED AN EMBRYOS…. WITH XY OR YY (BOY OR GIRL) … MEANING MOTHERS'S CHROMOSOME DOESNT DETERMINE CHILD'S GENDER, INFACT ONLY FATHER'S CHROMOSOME ONLY CAPABLE OF SELECTING GENDER.
    (PLEASE GIVE ME SOURCE OF THIS HADITH SO THAT I CAN PUT IT ON MY LIST OF WRONG HADITHS )
    5. MUSAND IMAM : YA THE JEW GOT IT RIGHT .. THESE SCIENTIFIC THEORIES WERE IN BIBLE AND TORAH TOO. ( LIKE MANY OTHER AYATS IN QURAN , IS REPETITIONS OF BIBLE AND TORAH), SO WHY THERE IS THIS QUESTION THAT HOW COME THE PROPHET KNEW ABOUT IT. IT WAS IN THE BIBLE … AND SOME PEOPLE AROUND KNEW ABOUT IT TOO. AS MANY ARABS HAD BUSINESS TIES OR LINKS WITH GREECE , ROME ETC DURING THAT TIME OR EARLIER WHO PASSED ON THESE KNOWLEDGES FROM GENERATION TO GENERATION
    6. "APPAREENT" OR "GROSS APPEARANCE" WHERE DID YOU FIND THESE ISSUES IN QURAN OR HADITH? IS THIS YOUR INVENTION OF WORDS? NOWHERE NOBODY TALKS ABOUT IT, SHOW ME ANY TAFSIR OF QURAN WHICH TALKS LIKE THAT. THE ISSUE HERE IS SIMPLE AND OBVIOUS WHICH IS WILL THE BABY BE MALE OR FEMALE ? AS THE EMBRIO HAS ALREADY DEVELOPED INTO BONE AND FLESH. YOU AMAZINGLY COMPLEXISIZING SOME SIMPLE FACTS SIMPLE QUESTIONS INTO COMPLEX SCIENTIFIC THEORIES BY INVENTING NEW WORDS AND INVOLVING THAT WORD INTO THE ISSUE.
    7. YES ISLAM IS RELIGION , NOT SCIENCE. SO WHY ARE YOU TRYING HARD TO MAKE IT LOOK SCIENTIFIC? DID YOU ANCESTOR DID THAT TOO? THEY DIDNT BOTHER . RIGHT? ARE YOU TRYING TO COPE WITH MODERN WORLD?
    8. FROM WHERE THE PROPHET GOT SCIENTIFIC THEORIES ( IF YOU CALL FEW LINES SCIENTIFIC THEORIES) . HERE ARE SOURCES …. A. BIBLE B. TORAH C. WISE AND KNOWLDGEABLE PEOPLE D. TRAVELLING AND MIXING WITH PEOPLE FROM OTHER COUNTRIES LIKE SYRIANS , PERSIANS , ….E. PASSED ON KNOWLEDGE AND EXPERIECE FROM ANCESTORS
    9. DONOT PUT YOUR WILD IMAGINATION THAT OTHER CIVILIZATION HAD THEIR OWN PROPHETS . IF YOU HAVE ANY FACT MENTION IT OTHERWISE REMAIN SILENT. ALL THE NAME OF PROPHETS THAT YOU KNOW ALL OF THEM WERE BORN IN JORDAN, SYRIA, PALESTINE, SAUDI, YEMEN…… NONE IN AMAZON JUNGLE IN BRAZIL, ALASKA, AUSTRALIA, GREENLAND , SOUTHPOLE FOR ESKIMOS, RUSSIAN , US, CANADA……..

  29. Kardo Muhammed Salh says:

    Anisur Rahman Anisur Rahman first of all it is not a single drop of semen, in arabic language means a drop of water , every word has two meanings first in language second in shari'a , no one claimed to be a drop of semen … but in language is true, it is like when you say sympathetic than means something with passion but in medicine it is a part of nervous system, there is not scientists in islam said that nutfa is a drop of semen scientifically. and the hadiths proof it . the hadith in sahih buxari in the beginning says : each of you will be in his mothers womb for 40 days nutfa… etc. deos it mean drop of semen will remain in mothers's womb for 40 days??? no one of our scholars said that .

    second bring you ancient greek knowledge here , i think non of them said human being are from fathers and mothers nutfa , non of them mentioned that embryo are created step by step. bring them here. however it is not compared to quran the aims are different.

    third : ancient knowledge or scholars' theory will not make quran's aya invalid, there is no reason for that. if it is true knowledge we beleive in it, if they said we are prophets again we beleive in them, that is why we beleive in muhammad PBUH as a prophet because he claimed to be a prophet.

    forth: where is the absolute wrong theory in ibn qaim's understanding of aya and hadith???? he just said boys are from fathers, but daughters from both of them!!! , then correct your knowledge regarding chromosomes , the mother is XX , the father is XY , there is no YY . if father is XY , mother is XX so ibn qaim's theory is absolutely TRUE. you are trying hard to misinterprete his theory. he didnt say that boy is only from father but rathar than said boy is created from father side.

    fifth: the prophet PBUH was illeterate, and he never read the bible nor torah. never mentioned in history that he read any book. even the orientalists who tried to criticize him never said that. you should say to yourself be silent or proove it.

    sixth : the hadith says after 40-45 days the angel asks allah it is male or female ? and allah says it is male or female and the angels will write it, the angel didnt ask will it be male or female like you misinterpreted, if it is like what you mentioned so why there is no any scholars said that ? i searched too much but i didnt find your misinterpretations no where in our islamic scholars' books, all what they said the sex will be written at that time regarding the explanation of this hadith, i dont know if there is another sahih hadith that may be your exact explanation. LET ME TELL YOU WHAT YOU QOUTE THAT IS ABSOLUTELY WRONG, MALE OR FEMALE SEX IS NOT DETERMINED DURING FERTILIZATION, EVEN IF Y CHROMOSOME IS PRESENT IT MAY BE FEMALE, THERE IS A GENE RESPONSIBLE FOR MALE APPEARANCE CALLED SRY GENE WHICH WILL BE ACTIVATED LATER BEFORE NEARLY 40 DAYS , SO IF NOT ACTIVATED YOU WILL HAVE A FEMALE WITH MALE CHROMOSOMES XY , OR YOU WILL HAVE AMBIGOUS GENITALIA, ALSO WE MAY HAVE MALE WITH XX CHROMOSOMES THAT CONTAIN SRY GENE DURING UNEQUAL CROSSING OVERY BETWEEN X AND Y OF THE FATHER DURING MEIOSIS THIS WILL SUPPORT THE HADITH BY YOUR EXPLANATION . YOUR EXPLANATION IS THAT ALLAH AT 40 DAYS WILL DECIDE IT IS EITHER MALE OR FEMALE THIS IS ALSO QUITE TRUE BECAUSE EVEN IF GENETICALLY Y CHROMOSOME WITH POSITIVE SRY GENE DETECTED EARLY THIS DOES NOT MEAN IT IS MALE , IT MAY BE INACTIVE. BUT MY HADITH THAT I POSTED IS NOT THAT ,THE HADITH DEOS NOT MEAN WHAT YOU DEFINED TO BE. THERE IS ANOTHER HADITH EXACTLY EXPLAIN WHAT YOU SAID BUT TILL NOW I DONT KNOW IT IS (SAHIH) OR NOT . IF I FOUND IT TO BE SAHIH I WILL SHARE IT WITH YOU WHICH SAYS WHEN THE ANGELS ASKS ALLAH IT IS MALE OR FEMALE? ALLAHS SAYS IT WILL BE MALE OR IT WILL BE FEMALE AND ALLAH DECIDE TO BE MALE OR FEMALE AT THAT TIME.

    seventh: i dont make my religon looks like science, and i do not cope it with modern science, and if science is againt hadith i prefer the hadith because one day the hadith will overcome , and i think you understand me well from previous point.

    eighth: the prophet muhammad PBUH has no sources for quran .. it is absolutely wrong to say he caught it from bible or torah! bring the clues . QURAN IS TOTALLY DIFFERENT FROM BIBLE AND TORAH EVEN WHEN NARRATING PROPHETS THAT ARE PRESENT IN BIBLE, QURAN NARRATE IT DIFFERENTLY BECAUSE BIBLE CHANGED BUT QURAN IS FROM ALLAH NOT BIBLE. even those against islam didnt said QURAN IS SECONDARY BIBLE after they studied the prophet muhammad's life, as you said proof it or be silent.

    ninth: really i dont know………. , by hadith we have more than 124000 prophets sent as messengers to people by hadith. according to quran allah sent his messengers to every nations worldwide.

    tenth: by the way i wonder if you could write to me your LIST of WRONG HADITHs , i think you are trying your best to proof the opposite…

  30. Kardo Muhammed Salh 1. LANGUAGE OF SHARIA ? DO YOU HAVE A SHARIA DICTIONARY LIKE DICTIONARY OF MEDICINE? SO YOU MEAN AN ARABIC WORD WHEN IT TALKS ABOUT SHARIA HAS A DIFFERENT MEANING ? DOES IT HAPPEN ONLY WHEN THE ISSUE IS CONTROVERSIAL ? OR WHEN SOMETHING NEED TO MAKE LOOK LIKE SCIENTIFIC ? HOW MANY SHARIA WORDS ARE DIFFERENT FROM ARABIC LANGUAGE WHEN IT TALKS ABOUT SIMPLE MATTERS LIKE “DON’T DEPRIVE THE ORPHANS”. NO NEW MEANING ABOUT THESE SIMPLE STATEMENTS . RIGHT?
    2. NUTFA SHOULD BE TRANSLATED AS DROP OF WATER BUT MOST TRANSLATOR TRANSLATED IT AS DROP OF SEMEN ( PROBABLY THAT’S WHAT IT LOOKS LIKE, THAT’S WHY). MY POINT WASN’T THAT. I WAS ASKING WHERE DID YOU FIND “SINGLE UNIT OF SEMEN” ?
    3. EXCUSE MY BAD MEMORY REGARDING X AND Y FOR PLACING IT OPPOSITELY. HOWEVER THE THEORY REMAINS THE SAME. YOU CAN PUT A AND B , INSTEAD OF X, Y. IT WILL STILL BE THE SAME CONCLUSION OF THEORY WHICH IS MOTHERS’ CHROMOSOME DON’T DETERMINE GENDER AT ALL. ONLY FATHERS’S CHROMOSE DETERMINES IF IT WILL BE BOY OR GIRL. MOTHER HAS NO CONTRIBUTION DETERMINING GENDER OF BABY. SO THIS HADITH IS OBVIOUSLY WRONG.
    4. I CAN WRITE A PHD THESIS PAPER ON ANCIENT EMBRYOLOGY KNOWN BY GREEK OR OTHER COUNTRIES’ SCIENTISTS. JUST TO MAKE IT SHORT FOR TIME CONSTRAINTS BELOW ARE FEW CONCISE INFORAMATION TO GIVE YOU A GLIMPSE OF WHAT THEY USED TO KNOW. BUT BE AWARE THAT THESE ARE PRIMITIVE SCIENCE JUST LIKE QURANIC DAYS . DEFINITELY NOT ALL GREEK THEORIES ARE CORRECT. SO I REPEAT THAT PLEASE DON’T TRY TO PROVE WHETHER GREEK EMBRYOLOGY IS RIGHT OR WRONG. MY POINT IS TO SHOW YOU THAT THEY ALSO KNEW MANY THINGS THAT IS MIRACULOUS.
    5. “GALEN” WAS ONE OF GREEK SCIENTIST WHO HAD DISCUSSED HIS THEORIES IN ONE OF HIS 40 BOOKS DURING AD 150. GALEN TAUGHT EMBRYO DEVELEPS IN FOUR STAGES. HERE IS A TRANLATION OF HIS WORK ……
    But let us take the account back again to the first conformation of the animal, and in order to make our account orderly and clear, let us divide the creation of the foetus overall into four periods of time. The first is that in which. as is seen both in abortions and in dissection, the form of the semen prevails . At this time, Hippocrates too, the all-marvelous, does not yet call the conformation of the animal a foetus; as we heard just now in the case of semen voided in the sixth day, he still calls it semen. But when it has been filled with blood , and heart, brain and liver are still unarticulated and unshaped yet have by now a certain solidarity and considerable size, this is the second period; the substance of the foetus has the form of flesh and no longer the form of semen. Accordingly you would find that Hippocrates too no longer calls such a form semen but, as was said, foetus. The third period follows on this, when, as was said, it is possible to see the three ruling parts clearly and a kind of outline, a silhouette, as it were, of all the other parts .You will see the conformation of the three ruling parts more clearly, that of the parts of the stomach more dimly, and much more still, that of the limbs. Later on they form "twigs", as Hippocrates expressed it, indicating by the term their similarity to branches. The fourth and final period is at the stage when all the parts in the limbs have been differentiated; and at this part Hippocrates the marvelous no longer calls the foetus an embryo only, but already a child, too when he says that it jerks and moves as an animal now fully formed …
    … The time has come for nature to articulate the organs precisely and to bring all the parts to completion. Thus it caused flesh to grow on and around all the bones, and at the same time … it made at the ends of the bones ligaments that bind them to each other, and along their entire length it placed around them on all sides thin membranes, called periosteal, on which it caused flesh to grow .
    it may be pointed out that it was early Muslim doctors, including Ibn-Qayyim, who first spotted the similarity. Basim Musallam, Director of the Centre of Middle Eastern Studies at the University of Cambridge concludes
    "The stages of development which the Qur'an and Hadith established for believers agreed perfectly with Galen's scientific account … There is no doubt that medieval thought appreciated this agreement between the Qur'an and Galen, for Arabic science employed the same Qur'anic terms to describe the Galenic stages" .
    6. JEWISH IDEA ON EMBRYOLOGY : LET ME QUOTE FROM A BOOK …..
    It has been said that the idea of the embryo developing through stages is a modern one, and that the Qur'an is anticipating modern embryology by depicting differing stages. However many ancient writers besides Galen taught that humans developed in different stages. For example in the Jewish Talmud we learn that the embryo has six stages of development. Samuel ha-Yehudi was a 2nd century Jewish physician, and one of many with an interest in embryology [22]. The embryo was called peri habbetten (fruit of the body) and develops as
    i. golem (formless, rolled-up thing);
    ii. shefir meruqqam (embroidered foetus – shefir means amniotic sac);
    iii. 'ubbar (something carried);
    iv. v'alad (child);
    v. v'alad shel qayama (noble or viable child) and
    vi. ben she-kallu chadashav (child whose months have been completed).
    Yet with the benefit of modern science we now know that the formation of a human being is a seamless continuation from conception to birth, hence the reason why there is so much contemporary confusion about abortion and embryo research. For if we develop as a continuous process it is impossible to draw hard-and-fast boundaries about when life starts. This makes a nonsense of the Qur'anic verse which says (71:14) "When He created you by (divers) stages".
    7. I CAN QUOTE FROM HIPPOCRATES AND ARISTOTLE ABOUT EMBRYOLOGY TOO. BUT THEN I HAVE TO WRITE A BOOK ON IT. WHICH WILL COME ONE DAY THOUGH…
    8. REGARDING XY CHROMOSOME YOU ARE PROVIDING NOW EXCEPTIONAL CASES FOR GENERAL FACTS. WHEN THESE THINGS THAT YOU MENTIONED MIGHT OCCUR IT DOESN’T CHANGE THE GENERAL FACT THAT AFTER FERTILIZATION AND FORMING A CELLS , THE GENDER IS ALREADY DECIDED. EVEN IF THE GENE RESPONSIBLE WORKS OTHER WAYS OR NOT, IT DOESN’T WAIT 40 DAYS TO DETERMINE THE GENDER. YOU ARE NOW OVERSIZINGLY EMPHASIZING THE GENE FACTOR AFTER FERTILIZATION. TELL ME IIN ONE LINE WHEN THE GENDER OF EMBRYO IS DETERMINED . THEN I WILL PROVIDE YOU ENOUGH MEDICAL SCIENCE ON IT.

  31. Kardo Muhammed Salh
    9. I WONDER WHY YOU BROUGHT UP CROSS GENDER ISSUES WHICH WAS VERBOSE AND UNCESSSARY SCIENTIFIC DISCUSSION IN DISTANTLY RELATED TOPIC OF OUR DISCUSSION.
    10. AGAIN YOU MENTIONED THE WORD APPEARACE ( PREVIOUSLY YOU MENTIONED “GROSS APPEARANCE” AND “APPARENT” WORD ). NO SUCH WORD OR ISSUE IN THAT HADITH REGARDING OBVIOUS AND VISIBILITY OF GENDER. THIS IS YOUR MEDICAL INVENTION.
    11. IF YOU DON’T MAKE YOUR RELIGION LOOK SCIENCE WHY DO YOU BRING SCIENCE IN RELIGIOUS DISCUSSION ? DO YOU KNOW THE DEFINITION OF SCIENCE ?
    sci•ence
    noun ?s?-?n(t)s
    : knowledge about or study of the natural world based on facts learned through experiments and observation
    ***Science (from Latin scientia, meaning "knowledge"[1]) is a systematic enterprise that builds and organizes knowledge in the form of testable explanations and predictions about the universe.[2][3] In an older and closely related meaning, "science" also refers to a body of knowledge itself, of the type that can be rationally explained and reliably applied. A practitioner of science is known as a scientist.
    12. IF GOD SAYS SOMETHING THAT’S NOT SCIENCE, THAT’S A BELIEF. SCIENCE MEANS KNOWLEDGE THAT WAS FOUND BY EXPERIMENT. IF YOU HEAR SOMETHING FROM YOUR FATHER WHETHER ITS RIGHT OR WRONG , ITS NOT SCIENCE.
    13. I JUST QUOTED UP THE EMBRYOLOGY THEORY IN TORAH. IF TIME PERMITS I WILL GIVE DETAILS ON SIMILARITIES OF QURAN AND BIBLE. ONCE AGAIN ITS SO MANY I HAVE TO WRITE A BOOK ON IT.
    14. YOU CAN NARRATE SAME HYSTORY IN TWENTY WAYS STILL FACTS REMAIN FACTS . HYSTORICAL FACTS ABOUT PROPHETS ARE VERY SIMILAR IN QURAN AND BIBLE. I HAVE A FEELING YOU DIDN’T READ BIBLE. DID YOU?
    15. QURAN IS NOT SECOND BIBLE. JUST SOME SIMILARITIES. FOR EXAMPLE THE THEORY ABOUT EXPANDING UNIVERSE IS ALSO MENTIONED IN BIBLE . NOT ONLY QURAN.
    16. IF THERE WAS ONE PROPHET IN MEXICO, DEFINITELY THE MAYANS AND AZTECHS WOULD WRITE ATLEAST ONE WORD ALLAH IN ALL THEIR HUNDREDS OF ANCIENT BUILDINGS. EXCEPT MIDDLE EAST YOU WILL NEVER FIND A SINGLE EVIDENCE OF ALLAH ANYWHERE IN THIS WORLD BEFORE THOUSANDS OF YEARS.
    17.

  32. LIST OF STRANGE HADITHS : (THERE ARE PLENTY MORE)

    HADITH 1 :
    IT IS FORBIDDEN TO LIFT ONE’S EYES TOWARD THE SKY WHILE SAYING PRAYERS, ABU HURAIRA REPORTED ALLAH’S PROPHET MOHAMMED SAYING “ PEOPLE SHOULD AVOID LIFTING THEIR EYES TOWARD THE SKY WHILE SAYING PRAYERS, OR EYES WOULD BE SNATCHED AWAY “
    HADITH 2 :
    NARRATED ABU HURAIRA , THE PROPHET SAID “ IF FLY FALLS INTO DRINK OF ANYONE OF YOU, HE SHOULD DIP IT INTO DRINK BECAUSE ONE WING OF FLY HAS DESEASE AND OTHER WING HAS THE CURE OF IT. ……BUKHARI VOL 6 NO. 537
    HADITH 3 :
    NARRATED AYESHA, THE PROPHET ONE NIGHT HEARD A MAN RECITING QURAN AND HE SAID “ ALLAH HAVE MERCY ON HIM, CAUSE HE REMINDED ME OF THIS AND THIS VERSE WHICH I FORGOT” . ……. BUKHARI VOL 6 NO 558

    HADITH 4 :
    NARRATED AISHA : A MAN CALLED LABID BIN AL ASAM FROM THE TRIBE OF BANI ZARAIQ WORKED MAGIC ON PROPHET MOHAMMAD(SM) HE STARTED IMAGINING THAT HE HAD DONE THING THAT HE HADNOT REALLY DONE…….. BUKHARI VOL 8 NO. 658

    HADITH 5 :
    THE PROPHET ORDERED THEM TO GO TO THE GROUP OF CAMELS AND DRINK THEIR MILK AND URINE. ………………..BUKHARI VOL 1. HADIS 234
    HADITH 6
    ONE DAY THE PROPHET MOHAMMED (SM) VISITED HER ( THE WIFE OF UBADA BIN AS SAMIT) AND SHE PROVIDED HIM WITH FOOD AND STARTED LOOKING FOR LICE IN HIS HEAD ………………… BUKHARI VOL 9 NO. 130
    HADITH 7 :
    The PROPHET MUHAMMAD SAW GIBRAEL WITH 600 WINGS……………… BUKHARI VOL 6 NO. 380
    HADITH 7 :
    IF SOMEONE SLEEP AND DOESN’T SAY PRAYER , THEN SATAN URINATES ON HIS EAR SAYS ABDULLAH. THE PROPHET SAID “ SATAN URINATED IN HIS EAR”. …..BUKHARI VOL. 2 NO. 245

  33. Shuaib Oladimeji says:

    TO: ANISUR RAHMAN, BUTTRESS YOUR POINT WILL REFERENCES AS YOU ARE SAYING THE WRONG THONG

Leave a Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.